Maintaining, monitoring, and keeping a mail server in good standing canbe pretty time-consuming. Having to worry about things like PTR records and being blacklisted from a false-positive stinks pretty bad. We also didn’t want to have to run and manage yet another machine. Fortunately, the recently released Amazon Simple Email Service takes care of this for us, with no fuss and at very cheap rates.
We (DUO Interactive) started using django-ses in production a few weeks ago, and things have hummed along without a hitch. We were able to drop django-ses into our deployment with maybe three lines altered. It’s just an email backend, so this is to be expected.
Our initial deployment was for a project running on Amazon EC2, so the latency between it and SES was tiny, and reliability has been great. However, we wanted to be able to make use of SES on our Django projects that were outside of Amazon’s network. Also, even projects internal to AWS should have delivery re-tries and non-blocking sending (more on that later).
Slow-downs and hiccups and errors, oh my!
The big problem we saw with using django-ses on a deployment external to Amazon Web Services was that any kind of momentary slow-down or API error (they happen, but very rarely) resulted in a lost email. The django-ses email backend uses boto’s new SES API, which is blocking, so we also saw email-sending views slow down when there were bumps in network performance. This was obviously just bad design on our part, as views should not block waiting for email to be handed off to an external service.
django-ses is meant to be as simple as possible. We wanted to take django-ses’s simplicity and add the following:
- Non-blocking calls for email sending from views. The user shouldn’t see a visible slow-down.
- Automatic re-try for API calls to SES that fail. Ensures messages get delivered.
- The ability to send emails through SES quickly, reliably, and efficiently from deployments external to Amazon Web Services.
The solution: Sea Cucumber
We ended up taking Harry Marr’s excellent django-ses and adapting it to use the (also awesome) django-celery. Celery has all of the things we needed built in (auto retry, async hand-off of background tasks), and we already have it in use for a number of other purposes. The end result is the now open-sourced Sea Cucumber Django app. It was more appropriate to fork the project, rather than tack something on to django-ses, as what we wanted to do did not mesh well with what was already there.
An additional perk is that combining Sea Cucumber with django-celery’s handy admin views for monitoring tasks lets us have peace of mind that everything is working as it should.
- boto 2.04b+
- Django 1.2 and up, but we won’t turn down patches for restoring compatibility with earlier versions.
- Python 2.5+
- celery 2.x and django-celery 2.x
Using Sea Cucumber
If you run into any issues, have questions, or would like to offer suggestions or ideas, you are encouraged to drop issues on our issue tracker. We also haunt the #duo room on FreeNode on week days.